Picture through The Pokémon Firm
Nintendo has acquired a probably harmful patent that might put them at an unfair benefit in gaming.
Nintendo has secured a brand new patent in the US concerning a really explicit online game mechanic. And this is able to all be high-quality and dandy if it weren’t a mechanic current in 1000’s of video games on the market, which might give Nintendo a formidable and unfair benefit.
Patent 12,403,397, granted to Nintendo on Sept. 2, might probably turn into one of the vital harmful instruments an organization has ever had in gaming. With the swipe of a pen, Nintendo now holds a standard online game mechanic, present in tons of of titles, in its proprietary fingers.
This patent, which Nintendo gained with none resistance from regulators in any respect since being filed in March 2023, is about summoning monsters to combat others for you and having management over that monster if no enemy is close by.
Whereas some would argue that is to do with Pokémon and the way these little critters conduct battle, the problem lies within the broadness of the patent’s descriptions, which means it might very nicely be utilized to numerous different video games the place you summon creatures to combat in your behalf (and might management them manually).

As per Home windows Central, these are the standards the patent outlines:
- The sport in query is saved on a drive on a pc, whether or not a PC or a console.
- The principle character may be managed in a digital setting.
- A “sub character” may be summoned into this digital area, who can combat enemy models both mechanically or through your personal command. And if there’s no enemy, this sub character can transfer round or be managed till an enemy emerges for them to combat.
As Home windows Central itself identified, tons of of video games may very well be argued to have these mechanics, which at the moment are Nintendo’s proprietary property, so many titles on the market might now be “infringing” upon them. Whereas patents or laws can’t be utilized retroactively, the patent’s March 2023 submitting means lots of video games which have come out since may very well be adversely impacted by it.
For instance, ARPG video games like Diablo 4 and Path of Exile 2 have Necromancer and Summoner construct paths you’ll be able to pursue, the place your entire shtick is having summoned monsters to combat in your behalf. So many different video games have comparable mechanics, particularly RPGs, MMOs, and titles within the fantasy style, the place Necromancers crop up as a rule.
Hell, even the likes of Baldur’s Gate 3 and its turn-based method may very well be fairly putting “infringements” of this so-called patent.
Nintendo now has the place to drive opponents into submission through the use of a patent approach too broad to be nearly pocket monsters and Nintendo’s pursuit of Palworld.

And don’t simply take my phrase for it. Per PC Gamer, online game patent lawyer Kirk Sigmon commented on this newest Nintendo patent growth, saying these patents mustn’t have been granted. He additionally mentioned it’s extremely uncommon that Nintendo noticed little to no pushback in any respect concerning these patents.
“I’ve no earthly concept how the Examiner might, in good religion, enable this utility so rapidly,” he mentioned.
He added, “unhealthy patents” just like the one in query “solid a large shadow on the business.”
“In my view, not one of the three patents I’ve mentioned right here ought to have been allowed. It’s stunning and offensive that they have been.”
Whether or not or not Nintendo makes use of these patents only for the aim of its Palworld lawsuits, or to bully the whole business into bowing earlier than it for essentially the most primary gameplay mechanic there may be, stays to be seen. The writer has been wont to pursue authorized motion for issues nice and small, and this patent, as broad as it’s, provides it authorized firepower like few companies have ever had.
Like our content material? Set Destructoid as a Most well-liked Supply on Google in only one step to make sure you see us extra often in your Google searches!
Printed: Sep 11, 2025 04:03 pm